UNIGIS Amsterdam Newsletter

  March
2006

Knowledge-scan on Spatial Data Infrastructures within the GIS Community
by Brian Kirwan

 
The rapid proliferation of spatial data, proprietary software and the implementation of location based technologies to many modern industrial and business activities has created a need to maximise the open exchange of information between geospatial enabled parties. Since the mid nineteen nineties a whole series of international, regional and national spatial data infrastructures (SDI) have been established.

I set myself the task of examining the state of knowledge amongst ordinary GIS professionals of these developments. In December 2005 I completed my MSc dissertation entitled Will ignorance be the real barrier to interoperability.

By examining the coverage of the subject in the specialised GIS press one was able to generate the following results:
  • With a 28% coverage record SDI is a popular subject choice and the depth of coverage is varied through time.
  • There are key weaknesses in dealing with issue of semantics, the treatment of the subject is sparse and poor compared to the interest in and treatment of, metadata and SDI in general
  • The average GIS specialist is much more likely to be aware of the legal context in realising SDI than have an awareness of the relationship between the costs and benefits
The summation of these led one to rejcect the hypothesis that ignorance will be a major barrier to interoperability.

The finishing up of the dissertation was the end of a long road started some four years ago and represented for me the realisation of an ambition which I have harboured for many years. Through the course of the study I learned to think and work on an abstraction level which I hadn’t done so before and thereby created an extra plane upon which one can ply one’s trade and that does not happen everyday!

The research dissertation, which is in English, can be downloaded in our Download area.

Brian Kirwan (2005), Is ignorance the real barrier to interoperability, Unigis MSc thesis, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam.

 

Vrije Universiteit, dep. Regional Economics ; De Boelelaan 1105 ; 1081 HV Amsterdam ; Room 3a-38 (Main Building) ;
Telephone: +31 (0)20-5986099
unigis@feweb.vu.nl